|
|
Home > DVDs > DVD 6979 GOTTERDAMMERUNG (Wagner)
DVD 6979 GOTTERDAMMERUNG (Wagner)
Product Reviews
| (3 Ratings, 2 Reviews) |
Average Rating:
|
Mr. Butterworth is right
David McKee
(Augusta, GA)
8/15/2018 7:32 PM
First the A/V report. Although this was filmed in HD somebody failed to remaster it for 16:9 TV sets, so you have to view the drama through a mid-screen 'window' box. Also, there is some pixellation just before Siegfried's murder and at the opera's climax but nothing ruinous.
If you're willing to trade a little eye strain to enjoy Yannis Kokkos' monolithic production, you will be rewarding, especially in the listening. Riccardo Muti achieves true grandeur in his reading but creates a comfortable frame for his singers, who reward him accordingly. First among many equals is Waltraud Meier's Waltraute, who nearly steals the opera with her monologue, operatic characterization at its finest. It says much for Jane Eaglen, heard at her majestic peak, that she is not overshadowed but really digs into what was, for her, the most congenial of the three Brünnhildes. Wolfgang Schmidt's prevailingly metallic tone (but ravishing at pianissimo) is somewhat of an acquired taste, but it's worth hanging in there for one of the most likable Siegfrieds on video. Demerits to Kurt Rydl for his shuddery tone, kudos to his ability to convey Hagen's alienation, loneliness and sense of dispoassesion. The nappy baritone of Eike Wilm Schulte and rich, expressive soprano of Emily Magee's incestuous Gutrune are well above the norm for these roles. One could go down the remainder of the vocal roster and not find a weak link, even if Franz-Josef Kapellmann's Alberich is more snarled than sung.
The Kokkos production is set among the director's elemental forms. The man has an acuity for psychology as well as stage pictures. Too bad his finale is obscured by too-circumspect TV direction. This DVD is a "Gotterdammerung" that will make you think and for that it is warmly recommended,
|
mr.
w. butterworth
(New York City)
7/22/2010 9:10 AM
A superb production. Muti brings out all the beauty and splendour of the music. The drama is presented with respect for Wagner's intentions. This video is indeed a treasure.
|
|

|
|